When more than 35 of America’s most revered pizzerias gather under one sky, every crust, sauce, and cheese melt speaks volumes about where pizza culture is going. That’s what Dave Portnoy’s One Bite Pizza Festival brought to New York in 2023 and 2024 — and what it promises for 2025. More than a food fair, it’s a case study in pizza history facts, culinary community building, and how the tools and ingredients behind iconic pies are evolving.
What Is the One Bite Pizza Festival?
- Launched in September 2023 in Coney Island, Brooklyn, by Barstool Sports founder Dave Portnoy together with events producer Medium Rare.
- The headliners: Sally’s Apizza, Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana, Lucali, Di Fara, and others who’ve shaped pizza lore.
- 2023 drew ~5,000 attendees; 2024 expanded to ~10,000 across multiple sessions on Randall’s Island.
- Ticket tiers ranged from General Admission to VIP/“Chef’s Table” style options. VIPs got extras: special pizzerias, drink access, better viewing, etc.
Memorable Moments, Rain & All
Not everything was sunshine and melting mozzarella.
- Weather chaos: In 2023, torrential rain battered the event, turning tents into sieves and slices into soggy challenges. Despite that, people queued in the downpour.
- Pizzerias in the wild: These pizza masters, used to their wood-fired ovens or brick ovens, had to adapt to portable setups. Some thrived, others revealed weak spots under pressure. For example, Sally’s Apizza and Monte’s got praise for crust & thin-crust performance; others struggled under soggy conditions.
Frank Pinello (of Best Pizza in Williamsburg) said:
“It’s a really beautiful thing for the history of pizza, all those pizzerias together.” Grub Street
He also noted that trying to queue for the highest-scored stalls took a patience reserve most festival goers didn’t know they had.
What the Festival Reveals About Pizza’s Roots & Future
Through the lens of One Bite Fest, we see threads of pizza’s past intertwined with fresh trends pointing toward its future.
Pizza History Facts You Should Know
- The participating pizzerias represent heritage: New Haven will forever be a benchmark, Apizza styles (like Sally’s, Pepe’s) carry century-old techniques. One Bite brings them together so attendees can compare directly what decades of tradition taste like side by side.
- The score-driven review culture, popularized by Portnoy, forces a reckoning with what makes a “good slice.” Crust char, sauce balance, shoe-leather style chew (for Neapolitan/Apizza fans), or crispiness for those who want crackle. Many pizzerias succeeded under festival pressure; others were undone by under-cooked dough or soggy portions.
Emerging Trends & Innovations
- Portable pizza ovens & cook setups: To pull this off, organizers brought 50+ ovens. That’s not just logistics—it’s a peek at how pizza making tools (from heat consistency to portability) are becoming more sophisticated.
- Ingredient integrity under chaos: When you move a pizza station outside, away from your normal line of supply, consistency of artisanal pizza ingredients (flour, cheese, wood vs gas, heat source, sauce) becomes testable. Some vendors maintained it beautifully; others paid the price in sogginess or inconsistent bake.
- Sustainability & sourcing: Festival events like this raise questions—how to source bulk ingredients sustainably (cheeses, flours, firewood) under carbon cost of shipping? Portnoy’s festival donated proceeds in 2024 to Santillo’s Brick Oven Pizza after it burned. That shows a recognition of pizza shop resilience and community responsibility.
Learn from the Festival: Tips for Home Pizza Makers & Pizza Shop Owners
If you love pizza (as I assume you do), there are takeaways for your own kitchen or business.
For Home Pizza Makers
To get closer to festival-level slices at home, focus on:
- Best home pizza oven: A reliable, high-heat oven (e.g. >700°F if using a stone or steel) replicates the intense, fast bake of wood-fired ovens. The kind used at One Bite are massive or portable professional ovens. If you’re investing in a home oven, get a model that gives you even heat and the ability to retain high temps.
- Pizza dough recipe: Use a high hydration dough (65-70% water relative to flour weight) with cold fermentation for 24-72 hours. This allows flavor development, open crumb, better chew. Festival-style crusts that held up under rain usually had good structure and strong crust strength.
- Artisanal pizza ingredients:
- Flour: Look for high-quality bread or 00 flour for the right protein strength.
- Cheese: Use fresh mozzarella; consider combining with aged cheeses for complexity.
- Sauce: Balance acidity, aromatics (garlic, basil), avoid watery sauces that weaken under moisture load.
- Pizza making tools: From peel to stone to oven thermometer, don’t skimp. A stone or steel helps get crust crisp; good isolation between sauce and crust prevents sogginess; peel makes transferring safe and consistent.
For Pizza Shop Owners & Suppliers
Festival environments strain every gear and supply chain. Lessons:
- Commercial pizza equipment quality matters: portable ovens, dough presses, mixers that handle bulk loads while keeping consistency. If one oven is off, slices suffer.
- Bulk pizza ingredients sourcing: lock in quality suppliers beforehand. Fluctuations in cheese, flour, wood/coal supply can bite when you’re producing many slices quickly. (Check our supplier directory )
- Operational efficiency under stress: One Bite required efficient queue management, staffing for high throughput, and contingency planning (weather, supply delays). Shop owners can learn from that for peak hours or special events.
- Marketing & loyalty building: Fest environments give huge exposure, but long-term growth comes from converting festival goers into repeat customers. Tools like POS systems, loyalty programs, online booking or ordering, and social media amplification are essential.
Affiliate Tips: Gear & Products to Up Your Pizza Game
Want to bring some festival-level performance into your kitchen or shop? These are tools and gear worth investing in:
- A high-temperature pizza oven (stone, steel, or deck style) that can handle rapid heat changes and give strong crust char. Check out models from artisan-grade brands .
- Pizza stones or steels that retain heat; ideal for home bakers who can’t install a full-brick oven.
- Specialty cookbooks that teach advanced dough handling, sauce balancing, and crust techniques. Great for both enthusiasts and shop owners seeking to refine their menus.
- Commercial dough presses and mixers for shops scaling up. They facilitate consistency, speed, and reduce labor strain.
FAQ: People Also Ask
What makes a great pizza crust under festival conditions?
A crust that can withstand high heat, maintain structure when sliced, and resist sogginess (especially in damp weather). Hydration, protein strength in flour, and proper ferment help. Portable or wood ovens with high searing temp are advantageous.
How should I ferment pizza dough for the best flavor?
Cold ferment your dough for 24-72 hours. The slower fermentation allows complex flavors to develop. Bring to room temp 1-2 hours before shaping. (Our full pizza dough recipe walks through the weights, timings, and technique.)
Which pizza shop equipment is essential for scaling up?
High-output mixers, reliable commercial ovens (portable or deck), dough presses, durable peel & stone gear, and a good POS/marketing system. Think reliability under continuous use.
How do food festivals affect supplier demand and pricing?
Sudden spikes in order volumes (cheese, flour, wood, specialized toppings) can strain supply chains. Sustainable sourcing and reliability matter more when scale surges. Having backup suppliers or preordering in bulk helps.
Why One Bite Fest’s Story Matters to the Pizza World
One Bite isn’t just about who makes the best slice that day. It’s emblematic:
- Community & recognition: It gives regional and legacy pizzerias a stage, letting their technique and history be sampled by fans who might otherwise only read or hear about them.
- Transparency & critique: When pizza is judged in real-time, with thousands of slices and hundreds of opinions, weaknesses are exposed. But so are strengths. That cycle pushes everyone to improve.
- Resilience & identity: Even in mud, rain, or imperfect setups, restaurants turned up. Pizzerias held their identity. Patrons listened to crust shatter, sauce burn, cheese melt with pride. That shows that part of pizza’s magic is durability—of craft, story, and taste.
What to Expect for One Bite 2025
The festival is scheduled for September 13, 2025 in New York City. One Bite will likely continue to scale up:
- More pizzerias from outside the Northeast region may be invited.
- Ticket tiers will likely push further premium for VIP / Chef Table / experiential access.
- Possibly even more attention to sustainability & supplier ethics, given increasing consumer demand.
If you plan to attend or follow virtually, come with an empty stomach, a critical palate, and gear for the weather.
This article contains affiliate links, which means Pizza Magazine may earn a commission if you make a purchase through them, at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products and services we genuinely believe in.
