A Fresh 2025 Ranking Blending Expert Reviews, Local Polls, and Viral Social Media Debates By Jay Trabelsi
The Great American Pizza Debate
If there’s one food that unites and divides Americans, it’s pizza. For decades, New York City has worn the crown as the undisputed pizza capital of the United States. But in 2025, the pizza landscape is more competitive than ever. From Detroit’s caramelized crusts to the Neapolitan-inspired pies of the West Coast, cities across the country are staking their claim as the new pizza mecca.
So, is New York still king? Or has another city stolen the slice spotlight? To answer this, we’ve blended expert reviews, local polls, and the hottest social media debates to bring you the definitive ranking of the best pizza cities in America. Whether you’re a die-hard New Yorker or a curious foodie, this list is guaranteed to spark discussion and maybe even inspire your next pizza pilgrimage.
How We Ranked America’s Best Pizza Cities
Our methodology is as layered as a deep-dish pie. We combined:
- Expert reviews from top food critics and pizza journalists
- Local polls and surveys from pizza-loving residents
- Viral social media trends (think TikTok, Instagram, and Reddit debates)
- Google search data on pizza-related queries
- Diversity and innovation in pizza styles
We also considered the number of award-winning pizzerias, the presence of iconic pizza institutions, and the city’s overall pizza culture.
1. New York City, NY: The Timeless King
Let’s be honest no list would be complete without New York at the top. The city’s classic, foldable slices are legendary, and its pizza culture is woven into the fabric of daily life. From the coal-fired ovens of Lombardi’s to the viral slices at Prince Street Pizza, NYC offers everything from $1 street slices to gourmet, chef-driven pies.
Expert Take:
“New York pizza is more than food it’s a way of life,” says Scott Wiener, founder of Scott’s Pizza Tours. “The city’s diversity means you can find every style imaginable, but the classic New York slice still reigns supreme.”
Local Polls:
A recent survey by Slice found that 78% of New Yorkers eat pizza at least once a week.
Want to recreate NYC-style pizza at home? Check out the best pizza stones and peels or that perfect crispy crust.
2. Chicago, IL: Deep-Dish Dynasty
Chicago’s deep-dish pizza is iconic, but the city’s pizza scene is far more diverse than many realize. From tavern-style thin crusts to artisanal Neapolitan pies, Chicago is a city that takes its pizza seriously.
Food Critic Insight:
“Chicago’s pizza culture is about more than deep-dish,” says Louisa Chu, food critic for the Chicago Tribune. “The city’s tavern-style pizza is having a renaissance, and new-wave pizzerias are pushing boundaries.”
Social Media Buzz:
#DeepDishChallenge and #TavernStylePizza have trended on TikTok, with millions of views showcasing Chicago’s pizza diversity.
Pro tip: For authentic deep-dish at home, try a cast iron pizza pan it makes all the difference.
3. Detroit, MI: The Underdog Rises
Detroit-style pizza has exploded in popularity, thanks to its thick, airy crust, caramelized cheese edges, and rectangular shape. What started as a local favorite is now a national sensation, with Detroit-style pizzerias popping up coast to coast.
Expert Review:
“Detroit-style pizza is the breakout star of the last decade,” says Daniel Young, author of ‘Where to Eat Pizza.’ “It’s craveable, Instagrammable, and uniquely American.”
Local Love:
Detroiters are fiercely proud of their pizza heritage, and local spots like Buddy’s and Cloverleaf are must-visits.
Want to try Detroit-style at home? Grab a blue steel pizza pan it’s the secret to those crispy edges.
4. Los Angeles, CA: The West Coast Innovator
Los Angeles has quietly become a pizza powerhouse, blending Neapolitan tradition with California creativity. From wood-fired Margheritas to vegan and gluten-free masterpieces, LA’s pizza scene is as diverse as its population.
Foodie Perspective:
“LA’s pizza chefs aren’t afraid to experiment,” says Bill Addison, LA Times food critic. “You’ll find everything from classic Neapolitan to Korean BBQ-inspired pies.”
Viral Trends:
LA’s pizza scene is all over Instagram, with spots like Pizzana and Prime Pizza racking up followers and foodie awards.
For a taste of LA at home, try a [portable outdoor pizza oven][AFFILIATE LINK] perfect for backyard pizza parties.
5. New Haven, CT: The Cult Favorite
New Haven-style “apizza” is a cult classic, beloved for its charred, chewy crust and simple, high-quality toppings. Frank Pepe’s and Sally’s Apizza are pilgrimage sites for pizza purists.
Expert Quote:
“New Haven’s apizza is the gold standard for many pizza aficionados,” says Dave Portnoy of Barstool Sports. “The white clam pie is a must-try.”
Local Polls:
A 2025 poll found that 92% of New Haven residents believe their city makes the best pizza in America.
Want to master New Haven-style at home? Check out the top-rated pizza ovens and dough mixers
Honorable Mentions: Cities on the Rise
- Portland, OR: Known for its artisanal, wood-fired pies and creative toppings.
- Philadelphia, PA: Home to a booming scene of old-school and new-school pizzerias.
- San Francisco, CA: Famous for sourdough crusts and innovative, chef-driven spots.
- St. Louis, MO: Provel cheese and cracker-thin crusts make for a unique local style.
The Social Media Factor: How TikTok and Instagram Are Shaping Pizza Culture
In 2025, pizza isn’t just eaten it’s shared, reviewed, and debated online. Viral challenges, pizza review accounts, and foodie influencers have put cities like Detroit and Portland on the national map. Hashtags like #PizzaTok and #PizzaReview have billions of views, and a single viral video can turn a local pizzeria into a national sensation overnight.
Want to join the conversation? Check out the best pizza-making kits and share your creations on social media!
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What makes New York pizza unique?
A: It’s all about the thin, foldable crust, tangy tomato sauce, and gooey mozzarella. The city’s water is rumored to play a role, too.
Q: Is deep-dish pizza really pizza?
A: Chicagoans say yes! It’s a hearty, casserole-like pie with layers of cheese, sauce, and toppings.
Q: Where can I find the best Detroit-style pizza outside Detroit?
A: Many cities now have Detroit-style spots, but you can also make it at home with a Detroit-style pizza pan.
Q: What’s the most underrated pizza city?
A: Portland, OR, is gaining national attention for its creative, high-quality pies.
Conclusion: The Pizza Crown Is Up for Grabs
So, is New York still king? For many, the answer is yes—but America’s pizza scene has never been more exciting or diverse. Whether you crave a classic New York slice, a gooey Chicago deep-dish, or a trendy Detroit square, there’s a city (and a slice) for everyone.
The real winner? Pizza lovers everywhere.
Ready to up your pizza game? Explore the best pizza ovens, pans, and gadgets and bring a taste of America’s top pizza cities to your kitchen.
If you loved this ranking, share it with your fellow pizza fans and subscribe for more expert pizza news, reviews, and recipes!
Affiliate Disclosure
This article contains affiliate links, which means Pizza Weekly may earn a commission if you make a purchase through them, at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products and services we genuinely believe in.
