Dark Mode Light Mode

The Best Pizza Awards: A Slice-by-Slice Blueprint for Pizza Lovers, Suppliers & Shop Owners

This insightful article was inspired by content originally published on National Post

Introduction

When the National Post dropped its much-buzzed-about Best Pizza Awards, it did more than crown the kings of crust. It spotlighted how craftsmanship, local ingredients, and smart strategy can make a pizzeria truly world-class and showed exactly what every slice fanatic, supplier, or pizza shop owner can learn (and profit from).

Today, we’re pulling the oven door wide open on the best takeaways: how you can elevate your home pizza-making, how suppliers can fuel the next big pizza industry trends, and how shop owners can earn their own “Best Pizza” status no matter their size or style.

🍕 What Makes a Pizza Worthy of an Award?

Each champion on the Best Pizza Awards list excels at three things:

  • Artisanal pizza ingredients sourced locally or thoughtfully.
  • Signature crusts made with passion and the right gear.
  • Community connection the story behind the pizza is as mouthwatering as the slice itself.

Chef Matteo Rossi an award-winning pizzaiolo from Toronto, hypothetically interviewed for Pizza Magazine sums it up best:

“Pizza is never just cheese and dough. It’s a story you can taste. When you combine craft with community, you’ve got a pie people will drive miles for.”

🍕 For Pizza Enthusiasts: Bring Home That Award-Winning Flavor

Forget bland freezer pies you deserve an award-worthy pizza in your own kitchen! Here’s how:

Get the Best Home Pizza Oven

Every top pizzeria relies on a blazing hot deck or wood-fired oven. Bring that fire home with the Ooni Karu Multi-Fuel Pizza Oven or go classic with the Best Pizza Stone for Crispy Crusts if you use your regular oven.

  • Keyword: best home pizza oven

Choose Premium Artisanal Pizza Ingredients

The award-winners stand out because they source local, seasonal, and high-quality toppings. For home pies:

  • Stock San Marzano tomatoes
  • Try heritage flours for dough: Type 00 or spelt blends
  • Add bold accents: truffle oil, burrata, or house-made sausage
  • Keyword: artisanal pizza ingredients

Nail Your Pizza Dough Recipe

A world-class pie starts with dough that sings. Use a pizza dough recipe with:

  • High hydration (65–70%)
  • 24- to 48-hour cold fermentation for deep flavor
  • Olive oil finish for golden crust

Pizza Pro Tip: Award-winning pizzaiolos often use a sourdough starter for complexity. Experiment and taste the difference!

  • Keyword: pizza dough recipe

Essential Pizza Making Tools

If your peel sticks or your toppings slide, you’re missing the right tools:

  • Professional Pizza Peel
  • Infrared thermometer gun to ensure your stone hits 500–700°F
  • Dough Scraper Kit for easy balling
  • Keyword: pizza making tools

🏭 For Pizza Suppliers

Award-winning pies raise the bar not just for diners, but for suppliers, too. Here’s how to feed the industry’s hunger for excellence.

Double Down on Sustainable Pizza Sourcing

Best-in-class pizzerias use hyper-local toppings even rooftop basil! Suppliers must offer:

  • Regionally grown produce
  • Heritage cheese and regenerative dairy
  • Sustainably farmed flour
  • Keyword: sustainable pizza sourcing

Smarter Commercial Pizza Equipment

Behind every award-winning crust is reliable gear:

  • High-Volume Commercial Dough Mixer for consistency
  • Space-saving deck ovens
  • Blast chillers for par-baked products

Small artisan shops want tools that deliver craft quality at scale.

  • Keyword: commercial pizza equipment

Level Up with Food Service Technology Pizza

Data drives modern pizzerias. Suppliers can help with:

  • Predictive ingredient ordering to cut waste
  • Loyalty program tools
  • POS integrations that link delivery apps, dine-in, and catering
  • Keyword: food service technology pizza

🏪 For Pizza Shop Owners

Dreaming of seeing your name on next year’s Best Pizza list? Here’s how to get there.

Shape Your Story: Pizza Shop Marketing Strategies

The winning shops stand out because their story is as good as their pizza. Use:

  • Origin stories: Who started the shop and why?
  • Local partnerships: Farm-to-pizza stories sell!
  • Instagram Reels: Show dough tossing, oven fires, or staff in action.
  • Keyword: pizza shop marketing strategies

Streamline Your Flow: Restaurant Operational Efficiency

Consistency is key. If one pie shines and the next disappoints, you’ll never make the list.

  • Invest in an Integrated Pizza POS System to reduce order errors.
  • Standardize your dough process with reliable mixers.
  • Use Pizza Delivery Software that optimizes routes and delivery times.
  • Keywords: pizza POS system, restaurant operational efficiency, pizza delivery software

Build Fans for Life: Customer Loyalty Pizza

The best shops don’t just get one-time visitors they earn regulars.

  • Reward loyalty with exclusive “Pizza Club” perks.
  • Create limited-edition pies using seasonal ingredients.
  • Host “Meet the Maker” nights to connect chefs and customers.
  • Keyword: customer loyalty pizza

📈 Bigger Trends: The Next Slice of the Pizza Industry

What’s next for pizza?

  • The rise of plant-based pizzas with craft toppings.
  • In-house flour milling for hyper-fresh dough.
  • Smarter AI ordering tools for small shops.

As Chef Rossi says:

“We’re seeing a renaissance. People want the neighborhood pizzeria vibe but with the quality of the world’s best pies. The bar is high, but that’s what keeps pizza exciting!”

🍕 Your Takeaway: Be Award-Worthy, Slice After Slice

Whether you’re a home baker, a supplier, or a shop owner:
✅ Upgrade your gear start with a Best Home Pizza Oven.
✅ Source the finest artisanal pizza ingredients and try a new pizza dough recipe this weekend.
✅ If you’re in the business, refine your story, streamline your process with an Integrated Pizza POS System, and keep your community at the heart of every pie.

The Best Pizza Awards aren’t just about trophies they’re about setting a standard every pizza lover deserves.

Affiliate Disclosure

This article contains affiliate links, which means Pizza Magazine may earn a commission if you make a purchase through them, at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products and services we genuinely believe in.

Keep Up to Date with the Most Important News

By pressing the Subscribe button, you confirm that you have read and are agreeing to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use
Add a comment Add a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Previous Post

From Freezer Aisle to Pizzeria: What DiGiorno’s Frozen Pizza Rankings Teach Us About Real Pizza

Next Post
Carnival cruise pizza station with freshly baked slices on a late-night deck

Cruise‑Ship Pizza Shake‑Up: What Carnival’s Late‑Night Cut Means for the Pizza World